Editor decision started nature neuroscience. However, not all appeals are successful.

Editor decision started nature neuroscience Editors decide whether to send a manuscript for peer review based on the degree to which it advances our understanding of the field, the soundness of conclusions, the extent to which the evidence Based on Nature’s website it looks like the editor sends a letter regardless of the decision so your editor is probably just writing the decision and it could be anything from accept without revision (hopefully) all the way to reject without reconsideration. 楼主，我也是同样的情况，7天后直接变成了editor decision started. decision making and the sense of agency. com ，顿时一阵激动，知道发生了什么，邮件标题是： Final decision for XXXXX。惊喜，终于收到了期盼已久的Decision---Accepted，万分激动！ 之后就是过两天->Editor assigned送给大编辑看看->Manuscript under consideration大编辑认为还行。再过两天->Editor Decision Started送给审稿人来看。经历了漫长的两个月之后同时出现了Decision sent to author->Waiting for revision。系统里给的时间表是（知乎做表天下最烂） Nature Communications投稿流程时间线: 目前个人发表的三篇NC文章从投稿到最终Online发表的整体时间分别为: 140天，250天和268天。扫盲小tips： 投稿后 (直接投或者Nature系列刊物transfer)，编辑初审，决定直接拒稿还是送审。 Aug 22, 2024 · 系统随后又走完了“Manuscript under submission->Manuscript received->Editor assigned->Manuscript under consideration”流程，接着第二天“Editor Decision Started”开始第三轮审稿。 审稿人回意见后，大编辑通知作者文章在原理上可以被出版在Nature，但需对论文进行进一步编辑。 On the day we submitted the article, an editor was assigned to us. Here the authors show that neural activity in orbitofrontal cortex alternates rapidly between the values of available options in The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in 2021年11月我的文章投稿 Nature Chemistry ，2023年4月收到确认接收的邮件。 从编辑直拒，到argue成功，收到审稿意见，修改后碰到审稿人跳反，中间还碰到负责这篇文章的编辑调离nature chem，坎坷路程历时一年半，生成4次投稿编号，终被接收，就用一篇流水文记录下吧。 我们有幸采访到朱霞博士，请她分享Nature Neuroscience论文发表背后的故事。第一作者访谈：首先祝贺你在Nature Neuroscience杂志发表论文，论文发表距离现在已经一年了，还能回忆起当时感觉如何吗？朱霞：那一刻非常难忘的，感觉如释重负，同时也非常激动。 Started 18th Dec, 2018. Prior to that, she received her PhD from Yale University, where she worked with Dr. The “Decision Started” status implies that peer review for your manuscript has been completed and the journal’s editorial board is in the process of making a decision. Jul 13, 2017 · 2014年5月1日晚上九点半，从深圳回来，在地铁上翻看手机（已经养成了随时接收邮件的习惯），突然邮件蹦出来， XXXXX@nature. 投稿science,3天秒拒 2. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 이거 리젝이라고 봐야할까요?? 교신저자분안 아직 메일은 안받으신것 같습니다. The status changed to "Manuscript under editorial consideration" last night without it changing to "Editor decision started" like in other examples. Nature is pretty slow at the moment. Magdalena is a geneticist by training and has considerable editorial and publishing experience: having started in Nature Publishing Group in 2001, she was Chief Editor of Nature Reviews Genetics, Senior Editor for genetics and genomics at Nature, and more recently Executive Editor for the Nature Partner Journals. I was expecting it to be that fast to be honest (7 days of median, average from submission to editorial decision). 2 – 3 First editorial decision. Please note that Nature Reviews Neuroscience reserves the The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in Jan 16, 2024 · editor decision started 7th april 23 manuscript under consideration 30th march 23 editor assigned 30th march 23 manuscript received 30th march 23 manuscript under submission 30th march 23 其他用户回复： 【CNS梦想家】 发表时间：2023-05-28 12:12:42主页 好友 来更新了，我们5. Nov 20, 2024 · This article shows the editorial process after Submitting a manuscript to a journal. But by the time Nae Neo - science launched in 1998, online journals were a well-established thing, and so we launched Oct 21, 2016 · This procedure is followed by most journals. By continuing to visit this site you agree to our use of cookies. Manuscript then goes into said editor's pile, and waits until it gets to the front of the line. 知乎，中文互联网高质量的问答社区和创作者聚集的原创内容平台，于 2011 年 1 月正式上线，以「让人们更好的分享知识、经验和见解，找到自己的解答」为品牌使命。知乎凭借认真、专业、友善的社区氛围、独特的产品机制以及结构化和易获得的优质内容，聚集了中文互联网科技、商业、影视 知乎，中文互联网高质量的问答社区和创作者聚集的原创内容平台，于 2011 年 1 月正式上线，以「让人们更好的分享知识、经验和见解，找到自己的解答」为品牌使命。知乎凭借认真、专业、友善的社区氛围、独特的产品机制以及结构化和易获得的优质内容，聚集了中文互联网科技、商业、影视 知乎，中文互联网高质量的问答社区和创作者聚集的原创内容平台，于 2011 年 1 月正式上线，以「让人们更好的分享知识、经验和见解，找到自己的解答」为品牌使命。知乎凭借认真、专业、友善的社区氛围、独特的产品机制以及结构化和易获得的优质内容，聚集了中文互联网科技、商业、影视 The Chief Editor/Editor-in-Chief together with the Handling Editor (where appropriate) and/or a member of the journal staff (where appropriate) will investigate the matter. During this time, my advisor told me that if it passed three days, it means it won't be instantly rejected. nature子刊editor decision started 状态 -回复-第四步：编辑审稿意见基于同行评审的结果，Nature子刊的编辑将准备一份审稿意见，这份意见会向作者传达。 审稿意见可能包括评审专家的评分和意见，以及编辑的意见和建议。 楼主，我也是同样的情况，7天后直接变成了editor decision started. Sep 20, 2022 · 投稿状态：Review completed、 Required reviews com‍pleted、 Awaiting AE recommendation, Awaiting decision, Editor Decision Started , Pending decision,Accpted等。 平均周期：几个工作日到一周。对于某些期刊，这可能需要更长的时间，尤其是在多人参与决策的情况下。 6 排版和出版 The editors make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: (a) Accept “in principle”, with mainly editorial revisions; (b) Invite the authors to revise their George started his editorial career at Communications Biology as an Associate Editor in 2020, where he handled papers related to molecular genetics, genomics, neuroscience, and microbiology. We consider various factors when deciding whether to send a paper out for review, among which is the advance provided over the Nature系列子刊原则性接收，回复格式及审稿人意见后，编辑又送给有意见的审稿人审稿了，文章会被据么？ 1 个回答 请问nature子刊投稿多久后能决定送审啊？ 之后就是过两天->Editor assigned送给大编辑看看->Manuscript under consideration大编辑认为还行。再过两天->Editor Decision Started送给审稿人来看。经历了漫长的两个月之后同时出现了Decision sent to author->Waiting for revision。系统里给的时间表是（知乎做表天下最烂） 1. 知乎上问了几个editor decision started 和 under consideration也非常接近的同学，都是被拒。 真是不大妙。 果然。 两个stage非常接近就是被拒的信号。 近几年投了四篇文章，从来没被拒过。 本次投稿标志不拒金身被破。 改格式另投。 round 2：不忘初心，牢记使命，投稿 PNAS。 12月10日：毫无动静。 目前的论文状态： 12月13日：毫无动静。 12月19日：毫无动静。 12月29日：毫无动静。 感觉审稿人去过圣诞了. My manuscript is currently at 'Editor Decision Started and would love your insight into what this means and if this happened to you, what was the outcome? Also, does the transition from 'Manuscript under consideration' to 'Manuscript under editorial consideration' indicate anything? Magdalena is a geneticist by training and has considerable editorial and publishing experience: having started in Nature Publishing Group in 2001, she was Chief Editor of Nature Reviews Genetics, Senior Editor for genetics and genomics at Nature, and more recently Executive Editor for the Nature Partner Journals. 当前位置： 首页 > 论文投稿 > 投Nature子刊，状态变为Editor Decision Started是什么意思？ 投Nature子刊，状态变为Editor Decision Started是什么意思？ 作者 3101251516 Sep 4, 2024 · 能在nature期刊或者子刊安排论文是非常了不起的，然而从投稿到接收可能也要历经坎坷，中间的审稿状态会不断的变化，有的作者可能要经过三轮审稿，有的是要经过四轮审稿，今天就以Nature Communications为例，分享几个投稿案例，更有助于大家了解审稿的情况。 • The handling editor reads the full manuscript to determine whether it is potentially suitable for the journal. • The handling editor might request additional information before making a decision. しかもNature Cell Biologyへの再投稿には、Reviewer 3のコメントには応えなくてもいい、と書いてある。 アピールをして粘ったことによって、NatureのEditorがNature Cell BiologyのEditorとこの論文について話してくれたようだ。 楼主，我也是同样的情况，7天后直接变成了editor decision started. The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in Jul 1, 2014 · What does the distribution of wait times for a editor decision look like for a manuscript submitted to Science or Nature? (You are not allowed to say "Gamma" unless you give a shape and scale para 这是我一作的paper，从Nature转到Nature Electronics后，送审了一次，审稿意见一正一负被拒，之后投到Science advances被接收。 这里简单聊一下，投正刊或者大子刊在审稿意见中，如果有一个意见是负面的，大概率会被拒稿，尤其是像我们这样的小组。 不过好在继续给了转移链接，导师说选择 Nature Materials。不知道是不是后面不送审都会给转移链接。 总结下我的经验，但不一定对，长达一个月没送审，NATURE可能给转移到子刊的链接，后面期刊不符合也大概率给转移。 I submitted to Nature Neuroscience about 9 days ago and it's been "under consideration" for about a week. 12月31日：依旧毫无动静。 新的一年，老天保佑~ 1月5日：毫无动静。 不慌，一般消息快的都是坏消息，好事多磨！ 1月11日：毫无动静。 1月19日：毫无动静。 目前的论文状态依旧是。 Shari Wiseman joined Nature Neuroscience in 2017, and became Chief Editor in 2021. Sep 8, 2023 · Update: the manuscript was rejected ~20 days later, and the editor recommended us transferring our paper to Nature Communications. Under what circumstances is Aug 12, 2020 · 五月中下旬投稿NG，12天后6月2号编辑决定送审，然后7月22号才找到审稿人，找了50天，我曾一度以为是新冠病毒的原因，不过21天后，状态又变成 Manuscript under editorial consideration，为什么有两个这种状态。第… Decisions are reversed on appeal only if the Editorial Board Member is convinced that the original decision was a serious mistake, such as a referee making substantial errors of fact or showing For each manuscript we used Springer Nature’s internal manuscript tracking system to extract name, institutional affiliation, and country of the corresponding author, journal title, the manuscript’s review type (single-blind or double-blind), the editor’s final decision on the manuscript (accept, reject, or revise), and the DOI. Status 테이블에는 editor decision started 후. Next you will see “Editor Decision Started”. But since the beginning, the status was "under consideration", until now. Nature editors will normally honour requests that a paper not be sent to Apr 9, 2023 · NMI（nature子刊）的Editor decision started是什么意思呀? 哎，我这个急性子，流程就到阶段持续了四五天了，想开个痛快 。 nature子刊editor decision started 状态-在这个阶段，作者应耐心等待编辑的决策，并尽可能完善稿件，以提高被接受的可能性。如果作者有疑问或需要更多信息，可以联系期刊的编辑团队进行咨询。nature子刊editor decision started 状态“Nature子刊Editor Decis Based on my experience with Nat Comm and RSC journals (and a lot of my colleagues had similar experiences, too), many times, editors will give a thorough read before assigning reviewers to judge the quality of work (if the work is worthy of the journal -- common with high IF journals). 26号拿到了审稿意见，两大修一拒 Jul 21, 2021 · Nature Human Behaviour - Authors can appeal editorial decisions, and editors will always consider each appeal carefully. The following questions should help you decide whether to accept an invitation to review for a Nature Research journal: Do you understand the role and responsibilities of a reviewer? Are you Apr 5, 2021 · Most journals typically take around 4-12 weeks to share their final decision. The status 'Decision started' indicates that the peer review process for your manuscript is complete and the paper is now with the editor. We use cookies to enhance your experience. But what I don't understand is the difference between editorial decision started and manuscipt under consideration. We would suggest that you wait for another 2 weeks before writing to the journal for an update. Jamie joined the Neuroscience & Psychology team of Nature Communications in October The following types of contribution to Nature Portfolio journals are peer-reviewed: Articles, Letters, Brief Communications, Matters Arising, Technical Reports, Analysis, Resources, Reviews Mar 4, 2013 · 投稿状态一般是先awaiting editor assignment，然后就是under review了，没有with editor这一阶段，所以在投稿前期文章是否送审并不清楚，但是这个杂志效率很快，从投稿到一审回来一般是40天，最长不会超过2个月。这个杂志编辑部对文章的要求跟biological psychiatry差不多。 问题标签：Editor Decision Started, Nature, 投稿状态 2 回复 0 赞 踩 iRobot 管理员回复于 5 年 前 有可能。 编辑有可能去休假了。 我这在审的文章开始就是给编辑了，一直没有送审或拒稿的消息，后来过了两周多说休假 […] Oct 16, 2024 · 之前自己的大课题的meta做出了一个很有意思的结论，于是把边角料给了nmi想发一个小文章，投稿11天后编辑表示很感兴趣，但是他们由于期刊发展问题小文章需要改成correspondence形式以热点问题形式发表，想了想我们本来就没做什么额外工作相当于这篇文章都是 Apr 26, 2021 · The chief editor assigns a primary editor for every paper — the assignment is based on which editor has the most relevant expertise — and the editor will read the paper and discuss it with at The following types of contribution to Nature Portfolio journals are peer-reviewed: Articles, Letters, Brief Communications, Matters Arising, Technical Reports, Analysis, Resources, Reviews The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in The first issue of Nature Neuroscience appeared a decade ago. I believe you will get an email 24-48h later saying it is or isn’t out for review. We look back on the history of the journal and the field. Nature welcomes authors' suggestions for suitable independent referees, but editors are free to decide themselves who to use as referees. audition 26,27, semantics 28,29,30,31, language 32,33, reading 34, decision . If the Editor-in-Chief decides the paper is within the Journal's remit, the Although we hope that the peer review files will provide a detailed and useful view into our peer review process, it is important to note that these files will not contain all the information Is this a letter to the editor or other non peer-reviewed article type? The turnaround time is unusually fast and I don’t see peer review reflected in the stages. The complainant will be Apr 13, 2008 · There has been a long controversy as to whether subjectively 'free' decisions are determined by brain activity ahead of time. • The handling editor decides whether to send the paper to peer review, often in consultation with other editors on the team. Rate limiting step here is just how long it takes the editor to render a decision. Making the decision and communicating it to the authors. In either case it sounds like the manuscript has gone through all the processing it needs to. Me using 50 % of the resources of this country's top academic computational grid to keep trying and failing to run a basic python script because I'm not good with computer but I want a cool protein structure prediction figures but these packages are not compatible why why is it not working Now (4 days after the initial submission), it is now under the status of "Editorial Decision Started". Hopefully, you will be informed of the decision soon. On day 4 they told the corresponding author that a subject editor had been assigned to handle my manuscript. "Editor decision started" means that the editor is actively reading the manuscript. The editor is probably going through the reviews to arrive at a decision. Irene Hames, in Academic and Professional Publishing, 2012. The specific process is as follows. 问下楼主是nature communications吗？另外从出现editor decision started 到收到拒信多久啊，接下来会更改新的状态吗？谢谢楼主 最近在帮一位教授朋友准备投稿Nature的论文，与编辑的打交道中，再次验证了我之前对Nature的录用要求，我分享如下，希望让各位学者对发表类似Nature等国际顶级期刊有启发和帮助。 要被Nature录用，自然要求非常高… May 8, 2023 · To mark the 25th anniversary of Nature Neuroscience, Shari Wiseman spoke with each of the past Chief Editors of the journal: Charles Jennings (1998–2003), Sandra Aamodt (2003–2008), Kalyani nature neuroscience Volume 26 | May 2023 | 712–714 | 713 Q&A Nae CD-ROM. Transfer consultations within Nature family journals qAuthors must opt in during submission of their manuscript to take advantage of this service qIt enables an editor to provide direct feedback on suitability for another Springer Nature journal qFor example, a Natureeditor may consult with editors at another Nature journal The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in Peer review in a rapidly evolving publishing landscape. 问下楼主是nature communications吗？另外从出现editor decision started 到收到拒信多久啊，接下来会更改新的状态吗？谢谢楼主 Nature editors go to every effort to ensure manuscripts are assessed fairly, Nature is not responsible for the conduct of its referees. You will also find this ebook useful: Current status에는 decision sent to author로. The editor has probably sent it to an expert in the field to get a feel on its impact/significance (not review). However, not all appeals are successful. The following types of contribution to Nature Portfolio journals are peer-reviewed: Articles, Letters, Brief Communications, Matters Arising, Technical Reports, Analysis, Resources, Reviews 发现不是这么回事，“under editorial consideration” 表示现在进入editor初步决定的时候了，要么送审，要么拒稿。 当然，80%的可能是直接拒稿。 编辑于 2018-10-28 23:52 之后就是过两天->Editor assigned送给大编辑看看->Manuscript under consideration大编辑认为还行。再过两天->Editor Decision Started送给审稿人来看。经历了漫长的两个月之后同时出现了Decision sent to author->Waiting for revision。系统里给的时间表是（知乎做表天下最烂） Then, in June 2021, Jake joined Nature Reviews Neuroscience as a Locum Senior Editor for 6 months, before assuming a permanent role at Nature Reviews as a member of the Cross-Journal Editorial The Associate Editor will inform the Editor of the Appeal Panel’s recommendations and the Editor will consider the recommendations and make a decision, which will then be communicated to the corresponding author within six weeks of receiving the letter requesting an appeal. Then, after about a week, the system status was updated to "editor decision started. They had a discussion with the editorial board of Nature Communications, and told me that our paper met NC's standards to send out for revidw. :-) So, it probably means that the associate editor (AE), who handles the manuscript through the review and publication process, had a look at your manuscript and made a decision on it, most probably for rejection Sep 26, 2018 · The handling editor then communicates the decision to the authors. Does this still mean that the designated editor started reading my manuscript just last night? 631K subscribers in the labrats community. 问下楼主是nature communications吗？另外从出现editor decision started 到收到拒信多久啊，接下来会更改新的状态吗？谢谢楼主 Jan 6, 2020 · If the author list changes after initial submission, all co authors must sign a change of authorship form; please discuss with the editor. Ten years ago this month, the Nature Neuroscience editors were obsessed with 你的sci论文是怎样被评审的？作者 / 李嘉晖 审校 / 李嘉晖 日期 / 2017年4月11日 「专栏目录」 「目录」sci，从入门到精通 「上期回顾」「第n讲」一篇sci论文的投稿过程（一） 「下期预告」「番外篇」学术科普网… May 30, 2023 · Nature Reviews Neuroscience - Artificial neural networks are being widely used to model behavioural and neural data. Stage 1: Initial quality check. I am anxious as I heard that usually the editor just needs 1 week to decide if a paper deserves to be sent for peer review or not. So don't feel upset! "Editor decision started" might sound like the editor is going to bench reject your paper, but that's not necessarily the case. . This stage includes checks on authorship, competing interests, ethics approval If authors wish to contest an editorial decision, we ask them to submit a form that organizes their arguments into categories that we find useful in reviewing our original judgments. they now start reviewing the paper Reviewing starts 5 Peer reviewers send their reports back to the editor within specified time frame Reports submitted 6 Editorial decision 8 If asked to revise, authors address peer reviewers’ comments and send a revised manuscript and a rebuttal letter back to the editor Paper revision 9 Editorial assessment 10 Feb 27, 2021 · nature的话，如果送审编辑会给通讯作者发send to peer review的通知邮件。如果没有收到这个邮件，在编辑手里呆了20天，那就是编辑还在考虑要不要送审，说明这篇文章在可送可不送的边缘，编辑还在考虑 这篇文章展示了向期刊投稿后的编辑过程。 第一阶段：初始质量检查 此阶段包括对作者身份、竞争利益、伦理批准和剽窃方面的检查。 我们对这一过程进行监督，确保您的手稿含有全部所需内容，以便我们的编辑和同行评审专家能够对您的工作展开公平和全面的评估。 第二阶段：指定编辑 当您的 I think the manuscript "under consideration" is an auto-update that appears as soon as an editor has been assigned. The arrangements for decision-making vary from journal to journal, ranging from the situation in small ones where a single editor makes all the decisions to that in large journals where a number of editors may be involved. Why my If the decision is not to send the manuscript for review, the Editor-in-Chief contacts the author with the decision. Feb 3, 2025 · It will guide you through the stages from the moment your article has been submitted until a decision was made. 다시 manuscript under consideration 있는 것으로 나옵니다. Jul 14, 2020 · Answer: Such quick changes may mean a glitch, but given that it’s a Nature journal, that’s unlikely. 投稿nature medicine，送审 Stage Start Date Editor Recommendation Started 31th Mar 21 All reviewers assigned 11th Mar 21 Manuscript under editorial consideration 26th Feb 21… May 12, 2021 · 19 days ago I submitted my manuscript to a journal under Nature publishing. Every step is described and will let you know whether any action is required, which you can then perform as appropriate by clicking on the respective manuscript, leading you to the submission system. After initial checks are complete, the manuscript is assigned to an editor, who reads the paper, consults with the editorial team, and decides whether it should 第一次投nature系列，不明白这个Manuscriptunderconsideration是啥意思，有没有过来人教一下我整个投稿过程应该是怎么样的呢？ 论文投稿 投稿求助 版块导航 投Nature子刊，状态变为Editor Decision Started是什么意思？ 已有17人参与 如题，under consideration几天后状态变成Editor Decision Started，是不是被拒稿了？ LetPub Scientific Journal Selector (2018-2021), NATURE published in 1869, ENGLAND. " 我之前投的Nature Electronics，等了快两个月编辑才送审，审完稿后又等了一个多月才给返修，第一次返修又花了半年多的时间。 反正他们处理稿件的每一步都很谨慎，所以效率显得很低，当然也可能是其它原因。 It doesn't mean anything other than the editor has started to look at your paper. Then, we wait. Angus Nairn. We found that the outcome of a decision can be encoded in brain Jun 6, 2016 · The neural mechanisms of subjective choice are largely unknown. Stavroula is the launch Chief Editor of Nature Human Behaviour. of Nature editors, I have also conducted web searches to trace their academic background, and I found that the majority of the editors (especially the Physics editors The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities: including this Nature announcement and earlier publications related to trials that started in Submission to first editorial decision: the median time (in days) from when a submission is received to when a first editorial decision about whether the paper was sent out for formal review or Aug 23, 2021 · What happens to a manuscript after submission? How does the editor reach a decision? What is the editor’s role during peer review? We take a look into the editorial process at Nature Cancer. buxq vngdcp utch mtm qxn qvewz mlnjgl whtrke gjegdb kbul gwjh rfqyssap cduq twbrhk qxe